About Us

Founder and staff have a combined 30 plus years industry experience. We are a local independent insurance agency located in Painesville, Ohio’s historic downtown square. We proudly serve the city Cleveland and it’s surrounding communities. We are a full service agency specializing in Automobile, home owner’s, Life and commercial insurance. We have the knowledge and capability to provide our clients with proper insurance solutions to ensure their financial security.

Lake Erie Insurance Pros, LLC is committed to doing the right thing. Not just for our customers for our community. Our staff donates time and resources in support of many local organizations. We proudly give back to the community that gives so much to us.

Michelle D. Colon Owner Michelle began her insurance career in 1991 and has been a licensed agent for nearly 20 years. She began as an underwriter, moved to claims, and than into sales with the founding of Lake Erie Insurance Pros in 2007. Michelle is very active in the community and is able to accommodate all of your insurance needs.	Anibal Colon, Jr. Office Manager/Fleet Services As an ASE Certified Heavy Duty Mechanic with a Class A CDL Anibal has the experience and knowledge to protect your commercial vehicles.   Weather you have a single 1 ton plow truck or a dozen semi tractor-trailers on the road, he has been in the drivers seat and understands your insurance needs.	Mildred Caraballo Customer Service Representative Millie joined our agency part time in 2008 as a part time customer service rep. She is always friendly and courteous and is eager to service your insurance needs.